Menu
Tax Notes logo

Companies, Trade Associations Ask Congress to Consider Ensign Repatriation Proposal

JAN. 30, 2008

Companies, Trade Associations Ask Congress to Consider Ensign Repatriation Proposal

DATED JAN. 30, 2008
DOCUMENT ATTRIBUTES
  • Institutional Authors
    American Electronics Association
    Information Technology Industry Council
    Medical Device Manufacturers Association
    National Association of Manufacturers
    Software Finance & Tax Executives Council
    U.S. Chamber of Commerce
    Abbott Laboratories
    Adaptec, Inc.
    Adobe Systems Incorporated
    Agilent Technologies Inc.
    Alcoa Inc.
    Altera Corporation
    American Power Conversion Corporation
    Apple
    Atheros Communications, Inc.
    Bell Corporation
    BMC Software
    Bristol Myers Squibb
    Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
    Cisco Systems, Inc.
    The Coca-Cola Company
    Eastman Kodak Company
    eBay
    EDS
    Electronic Arts Inc.
    Eli Lilly and Company
    Google Inc.
    Guardian Industries Corp.
    Hewlett-Packard Company
    Johnson & Johnson
    Kimberly-Clark Corporation
    Macrovision Corporation
    McDonald's Corporation
    Merck & Co., Inc.
    Microsoft Corporation
    National Semiconductor Corporation
    Oracle Corporation
    Palm, Inc.
    PerkinElmer, Inc.
    SanDisk Corporation
    Seagate Technology
    Sigma-Aldrich Corporation
    Silicon Graphics Inc.
    Square D Company
    Symantec Corporation
    Synopsys, Inc.
    Texas Instruments
    VeriSign, Inc.
    Xilinx, Inc.
  • Cross-Reference
    For the Ensign proposal, see Doc 2008-27136 2008 TNT 249-23: Proposed Legislation .
  • Subject Area/Tax Topics
  • Jurisdictions
  • Language
    English
  • Tax Analysts Document Number
    Doc 2008-27135
  • Tax Analysts Electronic Citation
    2008 TNT 249-25

 

January 30, 2008

 

 

The Honorable Henry Paulson

 

Secretary of the Treasury,

 

Department of Treasury

 

1500 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

 

Washington, DC 20220

 

 

The Honorable Harry Reid

 

Senator from Nevada

 

528 Hart Senate Office Building

 

Washington, DC 20510-2803

 

 

The Honorable Max Baucus

 

Senator from Montana

 

511 Hart Senate Office Building

 

Washington, DC 20510-2602

 

 

The Honorable Mitch McConnell

 

Senator from Kentucky

 

361A Russell Senate Office Building

 

Washington, DC 20510-1702

 

 

The Honorable Charles E. Grassley

 

Senator from Iowa

 

135 Hart Senate Office Building

 

Washington, DC 20510-1501

 

 

The Honorable Eric Solomon, Assistant Secretary

 

Office of Tax Policy, Department of Treasury

 

1500 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room 3120

 

Washington, DC 20220

 

 

Gentlemen:

The U.S. economy is facing a significant challenge, requiring immediate and meaningful stimulus. We therefore applaud the Administration and Congress' bipartisan efforts to develop a stimulus plan. We understand that the current proposal will release approximately $150 billion into the U.S. economy. As a further stimulus, the undersigned companies and trade associations respectfully urge you to include a temporary provision that would encourage repatriation of cash earned by foreign subsidiaries of U.S. companies for use in the U.S. economy. This proposal would inject twice as much (or more) money into the U.S. economy than the above proposal, but at a fraction of the revenue cost.

As you know, in 2004, Congress enacted a temporary reduction in the effective tax rate applicable to dividends paid to U.S. parent companies by their foreign subsidiaries. This led to the repatriation of nearly $360 billion (IRS data), which was invested in the U.S. and which added an estimated $10-20 billion in tax revenues in the first two years following enactment. Inclusion of a similar provision in stimulus legislation would result in comparable, perhaps greater, amounts of repatriation and tax revenues. Such legislation also provides temporary relief to U.S. companies from the challenges imposed by the United States' system of tax -- which imposes the second highest corporate tax rate in the world and taxes foreign earnings of home-based companies unlike most all other countries.

An injection of $360 billion (or more) into the U.S. economy at this time would provide a strong economic stimulus, as well as strengthen U.S. companies' ability to compete and thrive in the global marketplace on a longer-term basis. The stimulus to the economy would be immediate, significant, and far-reaching:

  • Injecting sizeable, much-needed capital into the U.S. economy, increasing U.S. banking system liquidity and helping stabilize financial and capital markets;

  • Adding federal and state tax revenues to fund critical government priorities, including other elements of the proposed stimulus legislation;

  • Strengthening the U.S. economy and financial markets through capital investment, R&D spending, job creation and retention, training, U.S. debt reduction, contributions to pension and other benefit plans, shareholder dividend payments, stock buybacks and other uses previously permitted in U.S. Treasury guidance.

 

Repatriating cash from foreign subsidiary earnings at a reduced U.S. tax rate fueled US economic growth in 2005-06. Bureau of Labor Statistics data indicates that, subsequent to the enactment and implementation of the 2004 temporary repatriation legislation, the United States experienced significant payroll growth (between 2/1/2005 through 1/31/2007), payroll growth that greatly exceeded such growth prior to enactment. Furthermore, Compustat analysis of companies that advanced the 2004 repatriation legislation reveals that these companies increased worldwide employment and R&D by a greater percentage following enactment than did all other publicly-traded U.S. corporations.

For the foregoing reasons, we urge you to include Senator Ensign's repatriation proposal in the stimulus legislation temporarily reducing the tax rate applicable to repatriation of cash held by foreign subsidiaries of U.S. companies.

Respectfully submitted:

 

 

American Electronics Association

 

(AeA)

 

 

Information Technology Industry

 

Council (ITI)

 

 

Medical Device Manufacturers

 

Association (MDMA)

 

 

National Association of Manufacturers

 

(NAM)

 

 

Software Finance & Tax Executives

 

Council (SofTEC)

 

 

U.S. Chamber of Commerce

 

 

Abbott Laboratories Adaptec, Inc.

 

 

Adobe Systems Incorporated

 

 

Agilent Technologies Inc.

 

 

Alcoa Inc.

 

 

Altera Corporation

 

 

American Power Conversion

 

Corporation

 

 

Apple

 

 

Atheros Communications, Inc.

 

 

Bell Corporation

 

 

BMC Software

 

 

Bristol Myers Squibb

 

 

Cadence Design Systems, Inc.

 

 

Cisco Systems, Inc.

 

 

The Coca-Cola Company

 

 

Eastman Kodak Company

 

 

eBay

 

 

EDS

 

 

Electronic Arts Inc.

 

 

Eli Lilly and Company

 

 

Google Inc.

 

 

Guardian Industries Corp.

 

 

Hewlett-Packard Company

 

 

Johnson & Johnson

 

 

Kimberly-Clark Corporation

 

 

Macrovision Corporation

 

 

McDonald's Corporation

 

 

Merck & Co., Inc.

 

 

Microsoft Corporation

 

 

National Semiconductor Corporation

 

 

Oracle Corporation

 

 

Palm, Inc.

 

 

PerkinElmer, Inc.

 

 

SanDisk Corporation

 

 

Seagate Technology

 

 

Sigma-Aldrich Corporation

 

 

Silicon Graphics Inc.

 

 

Square D Company

 

 

Symantec Corporation

 

 

Synopsys, Inc.

 

 

Texas Instruments

 

 

VeriSign, Inc.

 

 

Xilinx, Inc.

 

cc:

 

Senator Jeff Bingaman

 

Senator Jim Bunning

 

Senator Maria Cantwell

 

Senator Kent Conrad

 

Senator Mike Crapo

 

Senator John Ensign

 

Senator Orrin G. Hatch

 

Senator John F. Kerry

 

Senator Jon L. Kyl

 

Senator Blanche L. Lincoln

 

Senator Pat Roberts

 

Senator John D. Rockefeller

 

Senator Ken Salazar

 

Senator Charles E. Schumer

 

Senator Gordon Smith

 

Senator Olympia J. Snowe

 

Senator Debbie A. Stabenow

 

Senator John E. Sununu

 

Senator Ron Wyden
DOCUMENT ATTRIBUTES
  • Institutional Authors
    American Electronics Association
    Information Technology Industry Council
    Medical Device Manufacturers Association
    National Association of Manufacturers
    Software Finance & Tax Executives Council
    U.S. Chamber of Commerce
    Abbott Laboratories
    Adaptec, Inc.
    Adobe Systems Incorporated
    Agilent Technologies Inc.
    Alcoa Inc.
    Altera Corporation
    American Power Conversion Corporation
    Apple
    Atheros Communications, Inc.
    Bell Corporation
    BMC Software
    Bristol Myers Squibb
    Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
    Cisco Systems, Inc.
    The Coca-Cola Company
    Eastman Kodak Company
    eBay
    EDS
    Electronic Arts Inc.
    Eli Lilly and Company
    Google Inc.
    Guardian Industries Corp.
    Hewlett-Packard Company
    Johnson & Johnson
    Kimberly-Clark Corporation
    Macrovision Corporation
    McDonald's Corporation
    Merck & Co., Inc.
    Microsoft Corporation
    National Semiconductor Corporation
    Oracle Corporation
    Palm, Inc.
    PerkinElmer, Inc.
    SanDisk Corporation
    Seagate Technology
    Sigma-Aldrich Corporation
    Silicon Graphics Inc.
    Square D Company
    Symantec Corporation
    Synopsys, Inc.
    Texas Instruments
    VeriSign, Inc.
    Xilinx, Inc.
  • Cross-Reference
    For the Ensign proposal, see Doc 2008-27136 2008 TNT 249-23: Proposed Legislation .
  • Subject Area/Tax Topics
  • Jurisdictions
  • Language
    English
  • Tax Analysts Document Number
    Doc 2008-27135
  • Tax Analysts Electronic Citation
    2008 TNT 249-25
Copy RID