Tax Notes logo

Briefs in the Boechler Case

Posted on Nov. 23, 2021

The Boechler case involves the issue of whether the time period for filing a Tax Court petition in a Collection Due Process case is jurisdictional or a claims processing rule. Last week I provided a link to the excellent brief written on behalf of the petitioner. Also last week, the Supreme Court set the oral argument in this case for January 12, 2022.

Yesterday, seven days after the filing of the petitioner’s brief, amicus briefs were due in support of the petitioner.  Four amicus briefs were filed in support of petitioner’s position that the time period is not jurisdictional.  For those following this issue, the briefs are provided here.

The Tax Clinic at the Legal Services Center of Harvard Law School filed an amicus brief on behalf of the Center for Taxpayer Rights and the National Consumer Law Center. This brief focuses on the issue of equitable tolling.

Skadden Arps filed a brief on behalf of Federal Tax Clinics, Legal Aid Groups and Tax Professors. This brief argues that treating the time period as jurisdictional undermines Congressional intent and disproportionately harms low income taxpayers.

The National Taxpayer Union Foundation and National Federation of Independent Business Small Business Legal Center filed an amicus brief arguing that tax exceptionalism is an anachronism and that even if tax law is special the result should be greater tax protection through doctrines such as equitable tolling.

Regular Guest Blogger and procedural expert Lavar Taylor filed an amicus brief arguing that tax exceptionalism should not prevent equitable tolling, the IRS has argued for and received equitable tolling beneficial to it, and many statutory deadlines in the Code are amenable to equitable tolling and CDP especially so.  Lavar also spends time pointing out the impact of the lack of equitable tolling on individuals living abroad given the extremely short time for filing the petition in CDP cases and the mailing issues for those overseas.

Copy RID