Menu
Tax Notes logo

Textile Association Asks for Increased De Minimis Amount in 'Repair' Regs

APR. 13, 2012

Textile Association Asks for Increased De Minimis Amount in 'Repair' Regs

DATED APR. 13, 2012
DOCUMENT ATTRIBUTES

 

April 13, 2012

 

 

CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG-168745-03)

 

Hon. Emily McMahon

 

Acting Assistant Secretary for Tax Policy

 

Internal Revenue Service

 

Post Office Box 7604

 

Ben Franklin Station

 

Washington, D.C. 20224

 

 

Re: REG-168745-03

Guidance Regarding Deduction and Capitalization of Expenditures Related to Tangible Property

Comments of the Textile Rental Services Association ("TRSA")

Dear Ms. McMahon:

I am writing to you as President and CEO of the Textile Services Association of America (TRSA) 1800 Diagonal Road, Arlington, VA 22314 in support of the sections in the proposed regulations which establish a safe harbor allowing our members to elect to expense the total costs of any textile, uniform or dust control products having a value of $100 or less in the year that such products are placed in service.

I. About TRSA

TRSA is a trade association representing the entire textile services/commercial laundry industry. Our members provide clean linen, uniforms and dust control items to millions of customers every day. TRSA members in the United States employ approximately 200,000 workers and operate more than 1,500 facilities. Using modern technology and energy efficient equipment, TRSA members provide customers with clean goods that are processed in a manner that minimizes the environmental impact on water, air and solid waste disposal while reducing costs to our customers. By providing end users with a recyclable product processed with sophisticated technology, we are leaders in the effort to keep America "Green."

We estimate that TRSA members process more than 8 billion pounds of laundry every year. Our customer base includes restaurants, hotels, industrial plants, commercial facilities, transportation companies, health care institutions, manufacturers, service and retail operations, construction and others. The great majority of the textile, uniform and dust control items processed by our members cost $100 or less when purchased and are rented, including laundering and delivery, for a cost of under $2.00. As examples, our members typically purchase table cloths at a cost of $3.00 to $6.00 and rent those table clothes to customers for $.60 to $.70. Members purchase napkins for $1.00 to $2.00 and rent those napkins for $.08 to $.12. Members purchase uniforms for $35.00 to $55.00 and rent those uniforms for $1.10 to $2.20. Members purchase wash cloths for $.20 to $ .45 and rent those wash cloths for $.07 to $.10.

II. 2008 Testimony

On June 24, 2008, TRSA testified with regard to the proposed rule: Guidance Regarding Deductions and Capitalization of Expenditures Related to Tangible Personal Property. At that time, TRSA:

 

A. Indicated its support for the De Minimis rule but asked that the base number be raised from $100 to $500 and that the rule also include a provision that the base number be automatically adjusted annually for inflation.

B. Requested clarification that the proposed Section 1.263(a)-2 is not applicable to items properly classified as materials and supplies under Section 1.162-3, and

C. Requested clarification of Section 1.263(a)-2(d)(4)(iii) in order to minimize or avoid increased accounting burdens.

 

III. Comments on 2011 Proposed Rule

We appreciate the effort taken by the Department of the Treasury and the IRS in analyzing the comments regarding the 2008 proposed rule and making modifications as part of the proposed 2011 Rule to address the concerns raised. We believe that the 2011 version has significant improvements. However, we ask that the following issues be considered.

 

A. $100 De Minimis For Materials and Supplies.

TRSA has a continuing problem with the $100 De Minimis level for materials and supplies. In our 2008 comments, we proposed that the $100 De Minimis level be increased to $500. We also supported the concept of including an annual inflation adjustment to ensure that the dollar value of the safe harbor remained constant. The preamble to the 2011 proposed regulation recognizes that there is a need to adjust the $100 level but argues against increasing the amount to $500 explaining that to do so might cause possible inappropriate distortions of a taxpayer's income. Although the 2011 temporary regulations do give the Department of the Treasury and the IRS the flexibility to change the amount of the limitation by future Guidance, the regulations do not have an automatic inflation adjustment or an explanation as to why no such adjustment was included.

Using the "Inflation Calculator" on the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics website, if a taxpayer needed $100 to buy materials and supplies in 2006, the year these regulations were initially proposed, the taxpayer would need $112.93 to buy those same materials and supplies in 2012. Including an automatic inflation adjustment factor in the regulation would be of benefit not only to taxpayers but also to the IRS. It would ensure that the value of the benefit provided by the safe harbor would remain constant and avoid the need for additional annual regulatory action by Treasury and IRS. There are many Sections of the Internal Revenue Code that are currently indexed for inflation. We respectfully request that the $100 De Minimis level be increased and also be indexed for inflation.

B. Clarification of Application of the De Minimis Rule

TRSA supports the action of the Department of the Treasury in modifying the proposed 2008 rule to clarify the application of the De Minimis rule. As explained in the preamble of the 2011 temporary regulations which are incorporated as part of the proposed regulations, the 2011 regulations do not require that a taxpayer, in calculating whether its De Minimis amount exceeds the Sec. 1.263 ceiling, include the amounts deducted as materials and supplies costing $100 or less under proposed Sec. 1.162-3. This clarification is important to TRSA members and other taxpayers.

 

IV. Conclusion

Many TRSA members have an established history of deducting the cost of textile items including table cloths, napkins, uniforms, sheets, towels, healthcare textile and dust control items and others for Federal income tax purposes. The IRS and the Courts have repeatedly recognized the validity of this practice. See Prudential Overall Supply v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo 2002-103.83 T.C.M.1545, 1553; Rev. Rul. 69-81, 1969-1 CB 137; Rev. Rul. 78-382, 1978-2 CB 111; Technical Advice Memorandum 00213004. Establishing a bright line De Minimis test will assist both tax payers and the IRS in applying the rules relating to this deduction.

Thank you for your consideration of these comments.

Very truly yours,

 

 

Joseph Ricci,

 

President and Chief Executive

 

Officer

 

TRSA

 

Alexandria, VA
DOCUMENT ATTRIBUTES
Copy RID